So I posted this the other day:
We will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already do.
It will be our just deserts for having abandoned the Jews, ignored their warnings, turned against them, and even marched alongside their oppressors.
For three years, you useful idiots have been parading Palestinian flags, sporting keffiyehs, screaming “From the River to the Sea”, and recognizing a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (looking at you, Emmanuel Macron).
You have boycotted the only Jewish state in the world, vilified the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (aka “Zionism”), and spread the “Gaza genocide” blood libel. Did you really think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satiated? All you have done is embolden the monster and whet its appetite.
So you were worried about “colonization”? Look around. The only thing being colonized here are our own Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a victory banner, proudly waved amid the ruins of looted and vandalized historic buildings—a symbol of hatred for our civilization and everything it stands for.
It never ends with the Jews.
This was not a carefully argued analysis, but an impassioned cry from the heart, dashed off in the heat of the moment after watching the horrific scenes of wanton destruction in France. To my surprise, the post blew up: it received thousands of likes and reposts, was translated into multiple languages and was cited in several newspapers. I was flooded with interview requests, which I declined because I’m still working on my book.
As a sometime academic, however, I felt a bit embarrassed that my little rant contained no sources and little in the way of actual argumentation. A dereliction of duty! So, to make it up to you, I want to elaborate on one of its underlying ideas: that “useful idiots” on the left have been marching alongside Islamists, and that the Palestinian flag has become the joint symbol of hatred for Western civilization. This alliance between Islamist and left-wing forces is known in France as islamo-gauchisme (Islamo-leftism), and elsewhere as the Red-Green alliance. Does it really exist, and in what sense? Is it an orchestrated plot, or more of a rapprochement of convenience?1 And are the warm feelings mutual?
Come to think of it, I happen to have some academic expertise on the topic.
A conspiracy theory?
If we are to believe the vast majority of academics and journalists, Islamo-leftism is nothing but a “conspiracy theory”—a far-right fever dream in the same category as the Great Replacement or Judeo-Bolshevism. In 2021, more than 600 academics said as much in an open letter in Le Monde. As someone who has written several academic papers on conspiracy theories, I’m here to tell you: not only are these people clueless, they are part of the problem. They are abusing the valuable concept of “conspiracy theory” to shut down debate, much like the premature dismissal of the lab-leak hypothesis during the pandemic.
A conspiracy theory, in the pejorative sense, is an unproven and speculative hypothesis about a secret and sinister plot hatched by a relatively small group of people. Typically, the very lack of hard evidence for the conspiracy is taken as proof that the conspirators are fiendishly clever and have covered their tracks. In my academic work, I have dubbed such self-sealing theories the intellectual equivalent of a black hole: once you’ve dived in, it’s hard to claw your way back out.
The rapprochement between parts of the left and Islam is none of these things. It is hiding in plain sight and has been extensively documented. Granted, some of the leftist romance with Islam may stem from secret funding by Qatar and Iran—which would qualify as a genuine “conspiracy”2—but by and large these factors are incidental. The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.
Favorite victims
In its mainstream form, Islamo-leftism is simply the left’s love affair with Islam, which it regards as the religion of the downtrodden and oppressed. The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties. The perfect embodiment of this rapprochement is the concept of “Islamophobia”, which left-wing academics, journalists and intellectuals have brandished for decades to shield Islam from legitimate criticism, much to the delight of Islamists. Instead of contemplating the possibility that fear of Islam may be a rational response to certain Islamic doctrines (such as the death penalty for apostates) and to the attitudes of the many Muslims who endorse them, large swaths of the left have pretended that it is a form of mental illness, an irrational paranoia with no basis in fact.
Although he never used the term himself, Edward Said is the godfather of the modern concept of “Islamophobia”, which has served to deflect attention away from the actual teachings of Islam and the attitudes of Muslims ever since. Just like his intellectual forebear Michel Foucault, he was always obsessed with “discourses” about X, at the expense of the actual reality of X. So deeply has this pernicious pseudo-concept penetrated academia that there is even a whole academic journal devoted to it.
In a similar vein, leftists have consistently denied or downplayed the Islamic motivation behind terrorism and other forms of religious violence. During the wave of jihadist attacks in Europe in the 2010s, the left’s favorite apologists were people like Karen Armstrong and Mehdi Hasan, who insisted, in the face of overwhelming evidence, that “there is nothing Islamic about ISIS” and that jihadism has “little to do” with Islam. Since then, similar arguments have been made about rape gangs, gay bashing and honor killings, which are said to “occur in every culture”.
In my upcoming book The Betrayal of Enlightenment, I document how Muslims became the left’s ultimate victim group, a group that can never do anything wrong. If they appear to be engaged in any malfeasance, that is only because they have been provoked by people with real agency, mostly white oppressors.
Even progressives who don’t actively rally to Islam’s defense have often turned a blind eye to the homophobia, misogyny, antisemitism and violence against apostates that are rampant in Islam, while sternly condemning comparable tendencies among fundamentalist Christians. This double standard is in itself a passive form of Islamo-leftism: abandoning your own progressive values for the sake of one religion, because most of its adherents have a darker complexion and you’re afraid of being called racist.
An explicit alliance
The most explicit form of the Red-Green alliance is plainly visible on the streets of every Western city. For years, radical-left and Islamist groups have marched shoulder to shoulder at demonstrations and rallies against their common enemies: Zionism and Western imperialism. This unholy alliance is now held together by the all-purpose Palestinian flag, which no longer represents a people or an aspiring country, but an avatar onto which all sorts of fantasies can be projected.
For Muslims, it stands for the religious struggle against both the Little Satan (Israel) and the Great Satan (the United States), and for the religious duty to reconquer every piece of land that was once under Islamic rule. For leftists, it is the one thread that will unravel the whole fabric of the despised world order. That is the only way to understand the Irish writer Sally Rooney’s bizarre claim that “the liberation of Palestine represents the liberation of the world”. Although both groups have their reasons for obsessing about Palestine, it is mostly the Muslims who lead and the leftists who follow. If your favorite victim group hates the Jews Zionists with such fervor, surely those Jews Zionists must be uniquely diabolical.
Still not explicit enough for you? In 2006, one of the most influential academics on the left, Judith Butler, has described Hamas and Hezbollah as “progressive” movements that are “on the left”. She also insisted that the October 7 attack was not a terrorist attack but “an act of armed resistance”.
An even more full-throated endorsement comes from Charlotte Kates, the co-founder of the radical-left Samidoun, a front for the Marxist-Leninist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. In her public speeches, Kates openly calls for an “axis of resistance” uniting left-wing revolutionaries and Islamists:
This alliance is not merely the nightmare of our enemies, but is necessary and beneficial to the struggle of the peoples of the world against imperialism.
How much more explicit can it get? True to her word, Kates’s Samidoun celebrated the October 7 massacre by handing out pastries in Berlin and other German cities, and expressed unwavering solidarity with its Islamist comrades. And this is no fringe group: the very same Samidoun was invited to speak at my former university, Ghent, at a “Teach-Out about Palestine”.
Unrequited love
What makes this love affair tragic is that it is mostly unrequited. Whatever deluded leftists may think, their Green comrades hardly ever return the warm feelings. In reality, Islamists are cynically exploiting leftist naivety about Islam, and eagerly abusing the left’s terrible fear of racism. In his autobiography Radical, the former Islamist Maajid Nawaz recalls how his comrades in Hizb ut-Tahrir deliberately camouflaged their sectarian hatred behind the veil of “multiculturalism” and “tolerance”, and shrewdly played the “racism” card whenever someone dared to challenge them. (If you’re looking for a real conspiracy, there you have one.)
Islamists are happy to tolerate leftists as long as they are fighting a common enemy, but wherever they have actually seized power—in the Iranian Revolution, in Egypt after the Arab Spring, during the civil war in Lebanon—their left-wing fellow travelers have been brutally shoved aside, imprisoned or even executed. There may be “Queers for Palestine”, but there are no “Queers in Palestine”.
The French insurrection
It is no coincidence, then, that the riots, arson and looting in France were carried out by a motley crew of radical-left activists, North African Muslims and opportunistic casseurs (hooligans), with Palestinian flags fluttering everywhere. Or that the demonstrations were instigated and encouraged by La France Insoumise, the party of the far-left firebrand Jean-Luc Mélenchon, which panders to Muslim voters like no other European party, mostly by vilifying Israel, and receives between 60% and 70% of the Muslim vote in return (see Tomas Pueyo’s thorough analysis).
Nor should it surprise us that slogans like “Kill them in the name of Allah!” (aimed at the cops) could be heard during the protests, as could notorious rap songs glorifying the Bataclan terror attack.
Aggressive Islamists even forced their left-wing comrades to scrub words they deemed blasphemous, such as “Bismillah”, from their banners—a demand with which the spineless wimps meekly complied. Is there a better illustration of the left’s unrequited love for Islam?
In short: the radical left has been clutching this snake to its bosom for decades, while the moderate left keeps its eyes firmly shut. At this point, every single one of the 600 academics who haughtily dismissed the concept of Islamo-leftism as nothing but a conspiracy theory is part of the problem. Not because they are hiding evidence of secret collaboration with the Muslim Brotherhood and Qatar (although that is possible in some cases), but because they keep abetting and apologizing for Islamist fanaticism, betraying everything the left once stood for.
As I said: we will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish.
See Rob Henderson’s interview with Franziska Sittig, co-author of the 2025 book Intellectual Self-Destruction: How the West Gambles Away Its Future (the book is on my to-read pile)
See this shocking piece by Ella Kenan about the secret plans of the Muslim Brotherhood and Qatar, which amount to an actual conspiracy.



























Jean Genet was another Parisian poser who felt the need to constantly perform transgression, and this led him to speak frankly sometimes, which he did in 1974 when he said:
“Why the Palestinians? it was perfectly natural that I should be attracted not only to the most disadvantaged people but also to the one that most fully crystallizes hatred of the West.”
This I think is the root and emotional bond that defines the Left side of Islamo-Leftism: the desire to attack this thing called Western Civ, a 1789-style tantrum wherein the infantile Leftist displays his moral and intellectual superiority to all that came before, parricide on a grand scale for people who have a desperate need for meaning and purpose, live mostly in the eyes of others, and who want to be seen as a righteous liberator of humanity, however false or fantastical.
But when I think of the union of Islamists and Western Leftists I think of something like a Halloween prank where one side (Leftists) come with toilet paper and eggs, while the other (Islamists) appears with guns and Molotov cocktails. Western Leftists simply have no idea what they've signed up for, as only the most deranged among them have anything they want to kill or die for, whereas Islamists are happy to kill and die in the name of Allah.
Left-liberals have no theory of mind for Islamists and can only see them through their own ideology-colored glasses: as the poor brown oppressed Wretched of the Earth who just want justice and equality and who all Good People on the Right Side of History know to protect and support. They sacralize the Other, whereas for Islamists the Other is either an enemy and/or a future dhimmi.
One of the advantages Islamists have over Western Left-liberals is that Islamists are fully aware that they have a very specific ideology they've devoted their lives to (and are proud of it), whereas Western liberals are just as ideologically captured yet have no clue of this and would deny it to the end. Both sides will try to solidify their coalition and hold it together by binging on Jew hate and sharing a delicious feast of Jewish scapegoat. But this will turn out only to be an appetizer and once people get a taste for blood they're rarely appeased.
Thanks
Thank you for being such a stalwart ally. You have no idea how much it means to us.