Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Harry Neutel's avatar

That was a good response to the feed back. You used it to refine your underlying argument, and reduce the potential ways it could be honestly misconstrued. While I'm sure there will be plenty of people who will read this and remain wedded to the doctrine of logical fallacies, it should be mostly because of an attachment to them rather than a problem with your arguments. And that's all you can ask. You aren't their therapist, after all!

Jordan Raymond's avatar

Thank you, great article!

Your last point about place the fallacy list might play in education makes me smile, because it appears your opinion somewhat mellowed in the last 10 years while mine somewhat hardened! I was mostly saying this when I read you original papers (and blogs) back then, but now, I think it's not such a great idea. The "tags" are either simplifying what we do not want to simplify ("this is a fallacy, so no need to analyze further") or not really simplifying anything useful (because all arguments must be analyzed individually).

I think a better way to introduce critical thinking in a 101 course would be to "reconstruct" arguments, maybe using something like argument mapping (or something else), then work on analyzing them to eveluate their strenght. This way, you don't incentivize the students to become "referees" calling faults using a list of fallacy (or another kind of list), but you train them in the actual job of thinking about arguments. It's not going to be a magic bullet, of course, but it's at least doing something worthwhile.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?